Should Kathy take monthly payments or the commuted value of her pension?
Featured writing by Allan Norman · M.Sc. · CFP · CIM
Kathy, who built several years of pensionable service before resigning, has roughly a year to make a hard call: keep her public service pension as guaranteed monthly income for life, or take the commuted value as a lump sum she manages herself. A bank advisor nudged her toward the cash, which is exactly the kind of decision worth slowing down on. Allan lays out the trade-offs plainly. The pension offers indexed, government-backed income with no investing required, but leaves nothing to heirs, while the lump sum offers flexibility, the chance to build an estate, and the potential for growth, at the cost of taking on investment and longevity risk yourself. He notes there is no universal right answer, since it turns on health, comfort with investing, other income, and discipline. It is most relevant to public sector members facing this one-time choice.
Read Allan's full column on MoneySense.
Read on MoneySenseAnnuity vs. Pension: A Third Option Worth Knowing
Kathy's decision is also a useful lens on the broader annuity vs. pension question, because it is really a choice among three paths, not two. Keeping the monthly pension means her former employer's plan can keep paying her a set income for as long as she lives, already working much like a personal annuity. If she takes the commuted value instead, she gains two more options: she can use part or all of it to buy a commercial annuity from an insurance company, which may also provide income for life, or she can invest the money herself and draw it down over time.
Each path shifts who carries the risk. The pension is generally backed by the employer or plan sponsor. A commercial annuity is backed by the insurer that issues it, with organizations like Assuris providing some protection up to certain limits. Self-managed investing puts the growth potential and the ongoing decisions in Kathy's own hands. None of these paths guarantees a particular outcome, and commuting or buying an annuity is generally difficult to reverse. This is general information, not personalized tax or legal advice, since the right fit can depend on your own plan and circumstances.
Financial Post · October 2025
Laid off at 52, no pension and $250,000 in RRSPs. Is retirement a pipe dream?
Financial Post · April 2025
Is pension splitting worth it for a retired couple making about $70,000 annually?
Financial Post · September 2024
I don’t have a pension, so how do I determine when I can retire?
Have a question of your own?
Most of Allan's columns started with a reader's question. Yours could be the next conversation.
